avatar

Is Eli the Greatest QB in Giants’ History?

by John Fennelly on January 17th, 2012 at 11:15 am

The LoudMouths debate whether Eli Manning is the greatest Giants quarterback ever.

avatar

About John Fennelly

Managing Editor of SNY.tv's Giants Football Blog - the ultimate destination for New York Giants' news, opinion and entertainment. View all posts by John Fennelly →
  • Anonymous

    Seems inevitable doesn’t it – wonder if someday he’ll be doing TV ?

  • Anonymous

    Seems inevitable doesn’t it – wonder if someday he’ll be doing TV ?

  • Anonymous

    Yes. Over the last few years, he has finally turned into a top notch QB. On top of that, he knows how to win better than any QB the Giants have ever had.

  • Spider43

    It’s just a matter of time and health before he owns all the Giants passing related records. I had always preferred Roethlisbeger and Rivers to Eli, but Eli has finally grown on me this season to the point that given enough talented weapons, he’s a QB you can put your trust in. Before this year, I didn’t trust him much, including the Super Bowl winning season of 2007. This year, I think he finally matured to the point of being that “elite” QB that every team desires to have. Hopefully he can be our version of Joe Montana.

    • http://twitter.com/Krodsantana Sean Matrai

      Eli is a elite quarterback and has shown that when the Giants are under pressure he will always come through. He has constanly shown that he can match up with the best QBs in the game such as Brady,Brees,Rodgers, yes and even Ryan(who will put up good to excellent numbers himself). So yes he is the best Giants QB in history right now.

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/S4W4C2XHXYNVNMOIWTKHVGENP4 BigBank

    Yes. By the time he’s done, it won’t even be close. As of right now, he’s slightly ahead; but with all the football he has left…it won’t even be close. 

  • J. Williams

    Stat-wise it’s not even close right? So if he wins another Super Bowl he’s right on par with Sims but with much better stats projected and with a lot more time to go. Plus Hostetler finished one of Simm’s rings. Albeit with the disclaimer that QBs today have it much easier and Simm’s was much less of a golden child than Eli.

  • EliYES

    Eli is by far the greatest QB in Giants history and after tomorrow even the “haters” will have to admit he is an elite QB.  NY finally has a QB who is not afraid to take on the odds.  Go Eli and G-men.