avatar

Sunday Afternoon Hangover: Too Early To Worry?

by John Fennelly on August 22nd, 2010 at 3:51 pm

The New Meadowlands Stadium (NMS to many, now) had a strange feel to it last night.  The Giants did little to inspire their decreasing legions with their play. Steeler fans seemed to be everywhere on a night that provided less of what people came to see rather than more of it.

Either the Steelers are very good, or the Giants are very bad. Or maybe it’s the other way around. Who can tell?

Pittsburgh, whose season is being threatened by the impending suspension of Ben Roethlisberger, looks like a team that that has little to worry about in the quarterback department.  Byron Leftwich and Dennis Dixon both appeared to verrrrry comfortable taking snaps for Mike Tomlin’s crew.

On the opposing sideline, a different opera was playing. The Giants’ franchise quarterback, Eli Manning was out of uniform, still convalescing from head wound suffered last Monday vs the Jets.  His understudy, Jim Sorgi, is hoping his shoulder can heal in the next three weeks to avoid the year-long purgatory for the infirmed, formally known as injured reserve.

The very green Rhett Bomar was under center in the inaugural Giants’ home affair at NMS.  He struggled to make plays, and to the delight of the smattering of real Giant fans that can still afford to attend the games in person, he actually made a few. But, in general, he was out-manned by the notoriously staunch Steeler defense.

If Sorgi is sent to the gallows, the Giants will almost have to explore bringing in a veteran signal-caller. Names being bandied about last night were Jeff Garcia, Kerry Collins, Steve DeBerg, Earl Morrall and Norm Snead.

Another youngster, punter Matt Dodge, pounded a 63-yard punt, but then hit his next one about half that distance.  His inconsistency will both help and hurt the Giants this year. It’s a fact that fans are going to have to live with. It doesn’t look like the Giants will give up on him and bring in a veteran at this point.

Perry Fewell’s new defense played fairly well, but anytime they line up in Tampa 2, they give up yardage. They go from attack mode to read-and-react mode.  I’d rather see them die trying to stop the offense at the soonest point of attack than concede the chunks of yardage they did last night.  We’ve seen too much of that already…

Is it too early to worry? Never. I’m sure the team is aware of their shortcomings and is working on solutions. But, in the interim, fans worry.

avatar

About John Fennelly

Managing Editor of SNY.tv's Giants Football Blog - the ultimate destination for New York Giants' news, opinion and entertainment. View all posts by John Fennelly →
  • BigJohn

    See I thought the first team Defense played pretty well last night considering it was the 2nd pre-season game…I think we came out with a plan and we executed. The D-Line which we all agree MUST do better then they did last year played pretty well and they got after the QB and the ball carrier. They seemed to get penetration on almost every play that would make anyone’s wife or gf here more then happy and the best thing of all they seemed excited to be playing.

    Now in no way am I disillusioned here into thinking that our defense was perfect. As you said John our Tampa 2 was just giving up a ton of yards(more then normal) and our backups did not play like they did last week against the Jets. Alford looked rusty and Bernard looked to be on roller skates on some plays.

    But what I took out of last night’s game on defense was that we made a lot of good, solid plays, we made some bad plays but overall we came out excited and competed and we corrected mistakes that were made in the previous game. As a fan during the pre-season that’s all I can really ask of my defense. Now the offense? That’s a whole other story….

    • John Fennelly

      The defense played very well, with the exception of the plays where they dropped into a classic Tampa 2 and the instances where Bruce Johnson got toasted

      • BigJohn

        Yea I agree. Also, I cannot see that Greco kid being on the roster much longer after he failed to give Johnson safety help on that 68 yard TD pass Mike Wallace

        • John Fennelly

          Nice kid, but he’s a converted QB who’s still learning. Practice squad at best

  • AllGiants

    I was impressed by the defense’s showing as a whole last night. While they may be struggling running the Tampa 2, it’s still a big improvement over last season.

    - Tommy Barnett
    http://www.allgiants.com

    • John Fennelly

      I’m not a fan of the Tampa 2 and as soon as Phillips is u and running at game speed, they need to can it

  • jmc_47

    Agree that is not too early to worry. This past game we saw what the reserves can bring to the table, not much more.

    The real thing to worry about is the increased membership in the Giants’ infirmary. We can (almost) dismiss a lot of what we see in preseason (mostly backups playing). But if the health situation does not improve over the next week or two, then there is extreme reason to worry.

  • BigJohn

    Completely agree JMC…..I will begin to worry if in two weeks people are still injured and they have not had the opportunity to play with each other….