avatar

Read: A look at Kiper’s First Mock Draft

by Jon Schneider on January 25th, 2010 at 2:42 pm

A little less than two weeks back, ESPN NFL draft aficionado Mel Kiper Jr. came out with his first NFL mock draft. The following is what he came up with for first the Gmen, and then the rest of the NFC East squads.

New York Giants:(15) Carlos Dunlap, DE: Florida: “This is a high-value pick for the Giants, whose defensive line depth I feel has been overstated. There are makeup questions surrounding Dunlap, but for much of this past season, he was considered the premier pass-rusher in the college game. He has the potential to be like Jevon Kearse — the healthy version.” (Kiper)

I also think this would be a good pick for the Giants. We all know the defensive line starters (and backups) did not play anywhere near what they were expected to this season and it is to be expected that a few of them will be gone come the 2010 season. Osi may be gone, wouldn’t be surprised if Canty and one of the other DT’s were gone as well, so a strong defensive end  like Dunlap who seems to know how to get to the quarterback may be a good fit with Tuck and Kiwanuka for the future.

I would like to say that the Giants should look for some help at the CB position in the first round, however it just doesn’t seem like there’s anybody out there worth the selection this year except Joe Haden from Florida. I do not see the Giants trading up for the kid.

RB also wouldn’t be a bad way to look either, however according to Kiper the only one worthy of the first round is Jonathan Dwyer out of GT, whom I personally think wouldn’t be a good fit in New York.

Dallas Cowboys: (27): Bruce Campbell, OT: Maryland: Jerry Jones knows he needs to address the tackle position after the debacle he witnessed against Minnesota in the divisional round of the playoffs, and Campbell, while still learning, is a tremendous talent at this position. (Kiper)

I can see the ‘Boys going one of two ways with this pick. If Mr. Jones is feeling ballsy, he can try and trade up and go after one of the many safeties projected to go in this first round. If he wants to play it safe, he can wait on his pick, maybe hope the player “with the most potential” (that’s me I’m quoting) Taylor Mays is available, or just take an OT like Campbell. The Cowboys definitely showed a bit of weakness this season in terms of depth at the OL position, so drafting a young guy to replace the aging Columbo and Adams in the future would certainly not be a bad move.

Philadelphia Eagles: (24) Navorro Bowman, OLB: Penn State: The Eagles need an athletic OLB, and they get a lot of value by landing Bowman here. Bowman lacks size, but any parsing on measurable can’t overcome his great play on film. Could end up as the best at his position in this class. (Kiper)

Like the pick here for the Eagles. Clearly, their most glaring need is at the linebacker position. Akeem Jordan and Chris Gocong just aren’t going to cut it anymore. Love Bowman, frankly, i’d maybe like to see the Giants show him a little consideration as well.

Washington Redskins: (4): Sam Bradford, QB: Oklahoma: Mike Shanahan and the Redskins can get a quarterback here who might have been the top player taken had he opted to come out last year. The Redskins need to find their franchise quarterback, and when healthy, Bradford is an exceptionally accurate passer with an underrated arm. Shanahan also hit on his last QB selection when he drafted Jay Cutler in Denver. (Kiper)

Not much to say here. Shanny’s in town, and there’s no better way of sending the message that this team is his now than drafting the franchise QB for years to come. Obviously, the injury comes to mind, but I do not think anyone could question the potential this young kid has. Assuming he’s on track, this looks like the right selection in order to restore any faith from the Washington fans back in this team.


  • igs

    I don’t think this would be a smart pick for the Giants.

    Let’s look at this: If you fire Waufle and Sheridan than you’re saying that the players weren’t the problem, that the coaches and/or scheme were. But you go ahead and add yet another DE to a group that includes Tuck (who can play any line position and is my season MVP), Umenyora who is amazing, Kiwanuka who is still developing, and Tollefson who is a solid bacjup. So are you now saying that it was the players? Dude, you have to get your story straight. It wasn’t the players the 3 years under spags, so why is it the players now?

    Carlos Dunlap has way too many question marks to be considered a value at 15 and, because of that, he should fall out of the 1st round, unless Al Davis or Daniel Snider saves him. If Taylor Mays or Rolando McClain fall than they are great values at 15. (though I’m not so high on McClain.) Another option is to reach a little bit for Brian Price who does a lot of business in the backfield.

    • touchdownmaker

      I agree. Kiper is way off the mark here. We need a DT, LB, and S in a bad way. Brian Price would really benefit the LB core, so he solves two problems, by filling the hole at DT and giving the backers some help against the run. I think it should also be noted that we have not been all the great against the run.

      There will be some quality safeties in the second round. Look out for such names as Nate Allen, Chad Jones, Morgan Burnet, and Major Wright.

      They could use the third round to pick up a DE such as George Selvie.

      I personally think that we need an impact backer, but we might not be able to get one where we pick, so I would look to perhaps bring in Demco Ryans. Do you think we have the ability to bring him in? I would also like to bring in OJ Otagwei at saftey.

      • igs

        Touchdown,

        Mostly I agree with you. The speculation about Ryans is that Houston is going to offer him a long-term contract. But who knows what happens with an uncapped year on the horizon.

  • theyudla@gmail.com

    One of the last places the Giants need help is on the d-line.. especially at end. I have one word for Jerry Reese and Tom Coughlin: LINEBACKER! There is a much much greater need there than at end. I’m thinking Brandon Spikes.

    • igs

      Yudla,

      I gotta respectfully disagree. Jay Alford is the most athletic DT the Giants have. Maybe Cofeild and Robbins have a big gutcheck (no pun intended) this off-season, but when you watch tape of them you see a lot of near-misses. That’s an issue of athleticism, skill-be-damned.

      I also think Spikes will not make a good 4-3 MLB, specifically because of his lack of speed and lateral ability. Maybe if he’s there in the 2nd round the Giants should take a chance on him, but either way I don’t see him being successful in a pro 4-3.

  • BigRB

    At 6′ 5″ 290 Dunlap could be a beast anywhere on the line… but I agree Linebacker is very important…

    What do you guys think of London Fletcher for a year?… he may be on his way out of DC with the coaching changes and he was right at the top in total tackles the last couple of years…. Also Dansby is looking for a long term contract…

    I think we have better options in free agency than the draft.

    • igs

      BigRB,

      I don’t think Fletcher is the answer. I think Peirce is old enough that the Giants should be looking for his long term replacement. Dansby probably will be re-signed but if he’s there I’d love to see him in Big Blue.

  • Jon Schneider

    Although it may seem so, selecting a player where you seem to be strongest isn’t always the worst move…and for all we know, this defensive line could look completely different come draft time. It’s safe to say that Tuck and Kiwanuka are here to stay, but for the rest of ‘em…who knows?

    The one aspect of the Giants defense that was supposed to be the best in the league coming into it was our defensive line and our ability to get to the quarterback. Unfortunately, we fell way short of that, in part because of the coaching schemes, but it wasn’t completely their fault.

    I believe the most glaring need by far is to draft a CB, however if they’re not going to trade up and get Haden, then the next most important part of improving this defense is to improve its pass rush. I personally like Dunlap a lot. Aside from his recent DUI arrest, the guy has everything else going for him. 6’6 290 lbs, and quick around the edge.

    I would have no problems seeing Umenyiora out and a young Dunlap rotating in with the improving Kiwanuka at the edge.

    Just a thought…what would you guys think about Taylor Mays coming in and being coached into being a LB? he certainly has the tools, and I personally see this guy being a star

    • igs

      John,

      “I would have no problems seeing Umenyiora out and a young Dunlap rotating in with the improving Kiwanuka at the edge.”

      I just think it would be about the worst thing the Giants could do to get rid of Osi. Beside being one of the emotional leaders of the team, he’s a great athlete and we all know that he can get to the QB in the right scheme.

      Also, I wonder what you base Dunlap’s #15 grade on? Have you seen any flashes of brilliance form this guy because I sure haven’t. Do you think the Giants should drop Osi, create a whole at DE, then fill that hole with Dunlap? I just don’t see that happening.

      I also don’t see DB being the most glaring need. Between Webster, Thomas, and Ross, which player is a liability when healthy?

      I do think Taylor Mays would be a great value at 15. But I don’t see him playing MLB which is specifically where the Giants most glaring need is. In my ideal draft it would be 1st round – Mays, 2nd round – Arthur Jones, #rd round – Darryl Washington or Pat Angerer.