avatar

Shockey Adding Unneeded Fuel To Fire

by John Fennelly on October 13th, 2009 at 8:35 am

Let’s clear the air about all this ‘redemption’ talk before it gets legs. jeremy-shockey-072408

It’s being reported this week that former Giant and current Saint TE Jeremy Shockey has “a bitter taste in his mouth” about his Giants’ experience.

In the estimation of this Giants’ scribe Jeremy Shockey should have no ax to grind with the New York Giants.

His tale of deception is clearly in his own mind.  To be frank, he was the architect of his own undoing here in New York.  READ

The Downfall of Shockey

Shockey could not come to grips that the Giants were succeeding without him and proceeded to act like a child during and after the championship run.

Rumors began to circulate that Shockey was going to be traded.  Instead of approaching the Giants for clarity, Shockey and his agent at the time (Drew Rosenhaus, who specializes in representing NFL divas), began a war of words with the Giants in the media.

Then Shockey’s refusal to participate in a limited capacity at mini-camp in 2008, caused the rift to become irreparable. His ankle was still bothering him, but GM Jerry Reese asked him to take the field, show his face.

Shockey refused, instead opting to sit and sulk in the trainer’s room resulting in a shouting match between two.

What Shockey had not realized was that this was Reese’s team, now. In past years, his tirades and unprofessional behavior were tolerated by co-owners Bob Tisch and Wellington Mara, but with the passing of those two men a few years earlier, Shockey lost his greatest allies.  The Mara and Tisch heirs were not as hands-on as their fathers, which meant Reese had practically total control.

Shockey was traded to New Orleans in July of 2008 for a second and a fifth-round draft choice.  (The Giants used those picks this past April to select LB Clint Sintim and QB Rhett Bomar.)

Since Shockey’s final appearance in a Giants uniform (Dec 16, 2007), the Giants have won 22 of the 28 games they have played.

The Downside of Shockey

To be fair, let’s say that Jeremy Shockey was one of the best players the Giants have ever had. He was an All-Pro as a rookie in 2002 and was named to the Pro Bowl a total of four times.

He added a swagger to the Giants offense, and combined with Plaxico Burress and Brandon Jacobs, actually threw a scare in many a defense (esp. the Eagles).

But his presence brought as many detriments as it did advantages.

He openly challenged coaches’ and executives’ decisions in the media on more than one occasion (see the Seattle road loss from a few years back).

He had no respect for Eli Manning and was a disruptive force in the huddle and on the sidelines.

He only attended mandatory meetings and workouts, opting to stay in Florida while almost all of his teammates were in New Jersey.

He missed the end of every regular season from 2003-07 with an injury.

He did not participate in any of the Giants’ Super Bowl celebrations: the parade up the Canyon of Heroes, the rally at Giants’ Stadium, or the ring ceremony at Tiffany’s.

and finally, in my favorite game of all time…..the 39-38 playoff loss to the 49ers in 2003, perhaps the best displayed case of Shockey’s downside…..

Shockey classlessly taunted the 49ers’ bench after his second reception.  He tossed ice water into the stands at taunting fans behind the Giants bench, hitting a small child.

He dropped a touchdown pass in the 3rd quarter that would have been the deciding points. Instead, the Giants settled for a field goal, setting up the historic collapse.

So when you hear this redemption garbage being strewn at you by the clueless media talking heads, don’t buy it.  If they can’t sell this week’s Giants-Saints game as a clash of two undefeated teams, well, you know the rest….

avatar

About John Fennelly

Managing Editor of SNY.tv's Giants Football Blog - the ultimate destination for New York Giants' news, opinion and entertainment. View all posts by John Fennelly →
  • mark4212

    Shockey is a moron. Had he been a model citizen like he is in New Orleans he would still be on the giants. He acted like a little kid who lost his puppy. He cried and sulked and the giants had enough faith in Kevin Boss that they didn’t need Shockey anymore.

    Jerry Reese has proven to know when to part with guys, and how to replace them successfully, especially on the offensive side.

    This is now 100% Eli’s team. No more over-powering personalities, and the Giants are better off for it!

  • David Jacks

    Mark here is the difference between new york media and new orleans….you said “had he been a model citizen like he is in New Orleans, ” the thing is Shockey is still the same man child he was here as he is there. In fact this summer he was at a club in LA (called rehab ironically) and he had to be carted out by paramedics for what the media said was”dehydration (or what i what call drunk and stupid).” Bottom line NO doesn’t care, and as Shockey himself said the New Orleans people support him and are just nicer. Again when he was here he spewed homophobic comments more then once and was shocked that New York media did not embrace him. He is a good ol boy, with some backwards 18th century ideas, who belongs in a smaller market where his mouth can’t get him in as much trouble, hell they may even laugh off some of his blatant ignorance.

    That said Shockey is a force on the field and this is the game where we will miss boley and Phillips the most. Still I am sure sheridan will have a plan, but in the old spags d the seams were often the only weak points of the D, especially on blitzes that don’t get home.

  • eighteenandno

    I was a huge Shockey fan when he was here, but let’s be honest, HE forced his way out of NY, not the other way around. Reese tried desperately to keep him. The Saints had that 2nd and 5th round offer on the table for months, before the draft, and Reese denied it. He wanted to try and settle things with Shockey because of how talented he was. And despite the injuries and disruptions, he had some chemistry with Eli on the field. But Shockey has ALWAYS been about himself, and it’s no different this week. The Giants are better off without Shockey, and we’ve shown it the past 2 years now.

    • DSulls

      After the way they treated him before and during the Super Bowl, I can’t blame him for his behavior afterwards…. No ‘teammate’ should be treated the way he was….

  • eighteenandno

    Having said that however, Shockey presents HUGE matchup problems for us this week. Both he and Reggie Bush are the guys Im most worried about. I think we can do an adequate job on their WRs so long as the secondary keeps up its nice play. But Shockey and Bush will put A LOT of pressure on our LBs and Safeties this week.

  • Steal Home Jose!

    Going back to that awful SF game that we got cheated on…

    Didn’t Shockey also miss out on scoring a Touchdown because he attempted to run somebody over at the 2 yard line instead of taking the easy TD? And then the Giants ended up kicking a field goal instead? I could be mistaken, but it’s a memory in the back of my mind.

  • celticfool

    Great post, I agree….Read this article in ESPN by Len Pasquarelli. It supports John Fennely’s point of view and it makes me proud to be a Giant fan. Reese has done great work.
    Here is a snippet (link below)
    “In a league where the overall quality is diluted by franchises such as Oakland, and where the fates of some clubs rely on the performance of their most conspicuous players, stability and steadfastness are critical attributes. The Giants have plenty of both. It doesn’t hurt that the Mara family name has been on the letterhead since the franchise’s inception, or that Coughlin is one of only eight NFL head coaches who had five full seasons or more of continued employment with the same franchise entering this season. The stability of the franchise has engendered an even-keeled culture that doesn’t require a roster full of big names to succeed”

    http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/columns/story?columnist=pasquarelli_len&id=4555815